Doesn't Last Long
I'd been using N.Y.C. eyeliner and decided to grow up a little and get a "real" one. This one definitely takes more pressure to apply. The first day I used it I mentioned to a coworker I'd bought a lot of TBS stuff recently, including the eyeliner I was wearing. She said I didn't look like I was wearing any at all. It had completely disappeared, and I don't rub at my eyes a lot. I don't know what happened. Most days I notice it's gone after a few hours without my ever touching it.
August 14, 2013
I have the brown pencil. I like the color but the lead is too hard and it hurts my eyelid when I apply it. I usually have to go over the line more than twice and also seems to wear out quickly. I would recommend one of the Body Shop's other eyeliners.
July 7, 2013
Hard as a rock
I got the white one in store, and the employee showed it against the wrist etc etc, but once home, applying it to an eyelid has been impossible. I was looking for a soft highlight and white was the closest i could get, but I just can't use it. Eye pencils need to be softer than #2 lead. Seriously!
February 10, 2013
I usually get the Clinique roll-up quick liner for eyes because it goes on so easily and with good pigmentation and staying power. I also had a Cover Girl pencil that worked great the same, so I had decided to stop spending fifteen bucks on eyeliner and stick to the cheap drugstore stuff that I knew was a good product. I was almost out of my black eyeliner and I was already ordering some other Body Shop products during their buy 2/3-get 2/3 free sale, so I figured why not try this.
...I'm not impressed. I've definitely used much worse eyeliners, but this is not worth spending over ten dllars on. I'd rather spend a few more dollars on a good quality product, or, better yet, much less on a just as good product from the drugstore or e.l.f.
The pencil is in between too dry and just right. It's ALMOST creamy enough to apply easily, but I still have to go over my lash line a few times to get it to go on evenly with enough pigmentation. It has good staying power, but loses out on ease to apply and pigmentation.
November 8, 2012